Want More Sales? Stop Selling Like a Stranger

When I look at the stores that really take off, it’s never just because they have cute products or perfect websites.
It’s because their audience feels something when they show up.

That feeling—trust, warmth, familiarity—is what keeps people coming back.
Let’s talk about how to build it…and what can quietly break it.

1. Storytelling that feels human.
People connect with stories far more than sales pitches.
When you tell your story—the reason you started, the lessons you’ve learned, the moments that made you proud—you invite people to root for you.

Don’t overthink it. Tell the story like you would to a friend over coffee.
Ask yourself: What’s one thing I’ve overcome this week that my audience might relate to?
Those are the posts that stop the scroll.

SUPPORT OUR SPONSOR: Roku

2. Consistency — even when life gets messy.
You don’t have to show up every day, but you do have to show up regularly.
Your followers start to expect your energy—they trust that you’ll be there.

Pick a rhythm you can actually maintain and stick with it.
It’s the difference between “that brand I liked once” and “that person I always buy from.”

3. Fast replies and little gestures.
Connection doesn’t come from big moves—it’s built in the small ones.
When someone comments, DMs you, or replies to your email, try to answer quickly.
You don’t need paragraphs—a short, kind reply tells them you see them.

4. Authenticity — the messy middle.
Your audience doesn’t want “perfect.” They want real.
They want to know there’s a human behind the brand—one who laughs, messes up, keeps trying, and grows along the way.

Be transparent about what’s working and what’s hard.
Your honesty gives people permission to believe in themselves too.

SUPPORT OUR SPONSOR: The AI Report

5. Celebrate the small wins.
You don’t have to wait for the “big” moment. Every sale, review, and milestone matters.
Share it. Celebrate it. Gratitude is contagious—and it makes people want to be part of your journey.

1. Ghosting your followers.
We’ve all done it—life happens, and suddenly it’s been three weeks since your last post.
But when people stop hearing from you, they fill in the silence. They assume you quit, got bored, or aren’t serious.

If you fall off, don’t apologize—just come back.
Say, “Hey, I’ve missed being here.” That’s real, and people love real.

2. Changing your vibe every week.
Your audience needs to know what to expect.
When you constantly switch your tone, look, or message, people lose trust.
Pick your lane—your colors, your vibe, your message—and own it.

3. Copying others.
You can be inspired by other brands (we all are), but connection dies when your voice doesn’t sound like you.
The secret isn’t to be better—it’s to be different.
People fall in love with your quirks, your humor, your heart—not your polish.

✨ Here’s what I want you to remember:
Connection doesn’t happen overnight. It’s a relationship.
And like any relationship, it’s built through honesty, effort, and showing up—especially on the days you don’t feel like it.

Keep showing up. Keep being you.
Your people are out there waiting for that next post, that next story, that next spark of encouragement you bring to their screen.

You’re doing better than you think. 💛

Carina Hatton
Founder, Online Boutique Coaching

SUPPORT OUR SPONSOR: Pressmaster

Love this email? Forward it to a friend who needs a win today 💖